Ruh-roh, there's another Scooby-Doo reboot on the way. This time, the titular canine and Mystery Inc. are headed to Netflix. This new reimagining will also be the first live-action series in the franchise. That simple fact, and the tease that this new show may be a "mature" version, could give some fans flashbacks to Velma. But this latest offering has a chance to tell a successful, mature story without making the same mistakes as Velma.
Most of Velma's hate came from its misunderstanding of the franchise and forced social commentary. It was mean-spirited and offensive just for the sake of being an "adult" show. However, Scooby-Doo has tackled heavier concepts before without losing its heart. It's even catered to an older audience. If this new series wants to avoid what doomed Velma, it must preserve what Scooby-Doo is all about. Of course, this will never be enough to sway some fans who want the same show they grew up with. But taking risks and reinventing things isn't a bad idea for a 55+ year-old property. It just has to get things right.
Netflix's New 'Scooby-Doo' and the Failure of 'Velma'
Your Rating
Rate Now 0/10
Your comment has not been saved
Follow
Followed
Velma
- Release Date
- 2023 - 2023
- Network
- HBO Max
- Showrunner
- Charlie Grandy
Cast
-
Mindy Kaling
-
Sam Richardson
-
Constance Wu
-
Ming-Na Wen
WHERE TO WATCH
Streaming
BUY
- Directors
- Mindy Kaling
- Writers
- Mindy Kaling
Scooby-Doo possibly has the simplest premise in all of animation. Early episodes followed nearly the same structure. The gang visits some abandoned location, finds a monster, catches it, and reveals it's somebody in a costume who wants to scare everyone away. Rinse and repeat. Different series have played with the concept over the years, but it's remained the same at its core.
The new Netflix series seems to be an origin story for Mystery Inc., meaning this will be at least the sixth or seventh version of how they met. It opens with the gang celebrating their last summer at Camp Ruby-Spears — a clever nod to original Scooby-Doo creators Joe Ruby and Ken Spears. Friends Shaggy and Daphne find a lost Great Dane puppy that may have witnessed a murder. Hmm, who could the Great Dane be? They team up with Velma and the new kid, Fred, to get to the bottom of the case before all their secrets are revealed.
Related
The Scooby-Doo Storyline We'll Probably Never Get on Netflix but Truly Deserve
Scooby-Doo is coming to Netflix, so why not start with the darkest Scooby-Doo comic book story?
It's early, but this synopsis sounds promising, especially when you compare it to Velma, which tried to shoehorn social themes where they did not belong. It's a mystery why a show that discussed the size of Fred's you-know-what in detail was a flop. It made every character mean and unlikable, mocking the OG Scooby-Doo fans. Adding to the rage was the fact that a film like Scoob! Holiday Haunt was scrapped, while this thing was given two seasons. It did everything poorly, but that doesn't mean a mature Scooby-Doo is an impossibility.
How 'Scooby-Doo' Does Mature Themes Right
The early 2010s show Scooby-Doo! Mystery Incorporated is often cited by fans as the best series since the OG 1969 Scooby-Doo! Where Are You?. Scooby-Doo! Mystery Incorporated had both "monsters of the week" and an overarching series-long mystery. It covered heavy topics, like death, familial abandonment, the apocalypse, and ancient mythology, among many others. But it didn't include those topics just for the sake of including them.
Each theme served the greater mystery, allowing Scooby-Doo to tell a deeper, more complex story that still respected the audience and source material. Luckily, there was no talk of anyone's "no-no parts" either. The live-action component of Netflix's new offering may be a harder sell, as that's not something the franchise has experience with. Of course, there were those early 2000s movies that, although initially met with poor reviews, eventually found a cult following.
Related
Long-Time Scooby-Doo Actor Shares His Blunt Opinion of the Velma Series
Matthew Lillard shares the toll of voicing Shaggy in the Scooby-Doo franchise for 20 years, and his opinion of the Max show Velma.
7
A recent example of live-action success can be seen in the 2022 series Mystery Incorporated. Unrelated to the animated show, this take was a fan-made project that produced just one crowdfunded episode. After witnessing his parents murdered by a demon, Fred and Velma teamed up to get to the bottom of things. Shaggy and his non-talking dog were drug dealers, while Daphne was the popular girl who wanted to be prom queen.
More risqué than the cartoons, but also in line with what we'd expect from the characters. Everyone knows the urban legend of Shaggy being a stoner in Where Are You?. Their personalities were the same; they just aged up. This fan project didn't mock the original show or make everyone terrible humans. It found that balance between adult content and the Scooby-Doo we all know and love. Fans have praised it for using Scooby-Doo's established structure to tell a story that grew up alongside the original fans.
The Netflix show needs to get it right if it wants to succeed. We've seen that Scooby-Doo can tackle these heavy themes without losing sight of the franchise's heart. Scooby-Doo built its premise on catching bad guys in scary costumes. Dialing that up to feature actual killers isn't a reach. We don't know if Netflix will go this route or stick to its supernatural roots. In any case, it can succeed if it preserves the core personalities of the characters we know and respects the source material. Keep an eye out for news from Netflix on their newest Scooby-Doo take. And — not that any well-adjusted human would want to — Velma is still available to watch on Max.
